Maura Murray

Lighthouse 101 wrote:

<quoted text>
Your ask a question and answer your own question is a very Jenkonian Argument. Whether or not you are he I hope that he is well.

the repetition is telling; yes, Jenkonian.

Lighthouse 101 wrote:

<quoted text>
Your ask a question and answer your own question is a very Jenkonian Argument. Whether or not you are he I hope that he is well.

I think he posted not all that long ago.

SnowyB wrote:

<quoted text>
the repetition is telling; yes, Jenkonian.

Yep, after reading those posts it's the first name that came to mind for me too.

Mister Ed wrote:

Stick to the ten facts y'all. Otherwise the topix police come out and whine about it.

Look, don't pretend to be me.

And don't ask for help about a very serious situation if you don't actually need it.

dontletgo wrote:

I have a general question for anybody who feels like answering it:
Do you people really, honestly, think that she is still alive and ran away somewhere?
barely two months before she disappeared she got caught using a stolen credit card to order pizza directly to her dorm room, this is obviously not a street-smart master criminal we are talking about here.

Alcohol abuse will make you do some stupid stuff...

Lighthouse 101 wrote:

<quoted text>
Your ask a question and answer your own question is a very Jenkonian Argument. Whether or not you are he I hope that he is well.

A "jenkovian argument"????

¿Que?

Benjamin Franklyne wrote:

<quoted text>
Look, don't pretend to be me.
And don't ask for help about a very serious situation if you don't actually need it.

Not to butt-in, but didn't Mr. Ed come be4 Beavis and Butt-head??

http://www.topix.com/forum/city/brooklyn-ny/T...

Colbert VP wrote:

Maybe Mister Ed saw the thread for you in the Brooklyn, NY forum?

Tell Mr. Ed I could care less.

from the ground up wrote:

http://www.topix.com/forum/cit y/brooklyn-ny/TSNR94BO57IDCQ77 F

Proxy much?

dontletgo wrote:

<quoted text>
A "jenkovian argument"????

LoL. Jenkins..

Benjamin Franklyne wrote:

<quoted text>
Tell Mr. Ed I could care less.

LoL. At least some of the other names were creepy.. Mister Ed??

Benjamin Franklyne wrote:

<quoted text>
Tell Mr. Ed I could care less.

Dude, u sure u wanna piss off a talking horse?
j/k

@lighthouse: i will contend i was making a point rather than asking maruchan a question. And the point made has validity. there is no chance the police or any law enforcement agencies for that matter would tell the public that a murderer is using YouTube to mock a victims family. So a statement such as that does not constitute evidence that the maker of that YouTube video is not involved in maura murrays disappearance

you make a good point dontletgo.

while you didn't really address it, what about the video suggests guilt?

dontletgo wrote:

@lighthouse: i will contend i was making a point rather than asking maruchan a question. And the point made has validity. there is no chance the police or any law enforcement agencies for that matter would tell the public that a murderer is using YouTube to mock a victims family. So a statement such as that does not constitute evidence that the maker of that YouTube video is not involved in maura murrays disappearance

Whether you are my friend jenkins or not the Jenkonian Argument is created off self answered questions with one or more being answered incorrectly and then being the building blocks of an argument that will lead to a very high chance of fallacy.

So in this case:
In your premise you use the word "murderer" in a situation where a murder hasn't been proven to have taken place, let alone to attribute it to the creator of a you tube video. Therefore if a murder didn't exist - false assumption fallacy.

Every time they run an article or the disappeared episode new people pop up asking the same questions that have been Answered over and over.

This is a thinly veiled threat:

http://www.topix.com/forum/city/colma-ca/TPDU...

Colma happens to be where there are a lot of cemeteries around here.

It seems that you are trying to deliver a message to me.

I guess you aren't happy that I'm paying attention now and that I'm not going to let you attempt to impersonate some of my less well thought out posts.

However, yours are actually quite different from mine because they include a vindictive, evil and harmful quality I never had or will have.

Your threats don't scare me.

krome kola wrote:

you make a good point dontletgo.
while you didn't really address it, what about the video suggests guilt?

The video was entitled "happy anniversary" was put out on the anniversary of her disappearance and entailed a man almost ghoulishly laughing for approximately a minute and then concluding with a wink. It appears that the creator of the video is implying that he is potentially involved in her disappearance or at least has information regarding it. then consider the other videos that he created and posted on YouTube. they appeared to be an attempt to convey some sort of bizarre cryptic message as if he was trying to say if you can decipher this message you will know what happened to maura murray.
presumably just bizarre ravings of a lunatic that is more or less harmless but in the videos he appears to be implying he is not harmless. he could possibly be a very dangerous individual. he is exhibiting some rather antisocial behaviors. he seems to have knowledge of this case possibly even inside knowledge if some of the statements he has made in the past are true. this person also has a criminal record and not a non violent record for something minor like drug possession. It is.for threatening to kill a family member.
surprisingly there is a lot of support for beagle on this message board. many posts about how harmless he is and how smart he is but how well do these people know him? Do they know him off of the board? what are they using to drive the conclusion that he is so harmless? we know he has threatened to murder a family member and we know he at best appears to enjoy mocking a family that is stuck in a permanent mourning process and implying that he has something to do with the disappearance of a young woman. people that exhibit antisocial behaviors are often the very type of people that commit violent crimes.

I dont know that beagle is involved with this disappearance anymore than any of the other posters on this board know that he is not. the only real thing that we know about him is that he displays antisocial behaviors which is not a good indication about his character